There are two main
problems with education in Haiti, both equally troubling in my mind. Only 30%
of children finish the 6th grade. 47% of the population is
illiterate and only 1% of the population has a college degree. Woman are
disproportionately unable to access education, as are those who live in rural
areas. Many schools are private, so if a family cannot pay, their children
cannot be educated, which is a problem generation after generation.
The other side of
this coin is that the schools that people can go to in Haiti are frequently
quite awful. All age groups are shoved together into overheated rooms with no
books and rows and rows of benches. It is common for teachers to just not show
up for class and some schools are run for a profit, with the students education
coming as a low priority. The conclusion of this is that parents do so much to
try to pay for their children to go to school, but the education that they get
is basically a waste of their investment.
Children pouring out of a one-room school house.
There is a problem with
the philosophy behind education in Haiti. In the USA, educators use dynamic and
varied lesson plans: think back to elementary school, when your desks were in “pods”
and you were doing experiments, critical thinking exercises, and group work.
You were challenged to find answers on your own and those lessons often stuck.
In Haiti, all education is based on a system of rote memorization (think about
how you learned your times tables). So French class means “copy these sentences
off of the board,” biology means “Memorize these definitions word for word” and
literature class means “memorize these famous quotations.” The first time I put
vocabulary words on the board, my students all started repeating them back to
me with no prompting: they were very comfortable with this style of learning.
They were much less comfortable when I tried to make them do critical thinking
questions about a reading passage in groups: repetition and memorization are
easy for them, critical thinking is not.
Students lined up in rows during class. Uniforms
are incredibly important to people in Haiti: it is a status symbol to be able
to see your child walking around town, proving that he or she goes to school.
They are so proud to be able to go to school and send their children to school
President Martelly’s
top priority is education: the government is making some investments in the
area and some private schools are now being nationalized and made public. The
US Secretary of Education was in Haiti this week, pledging support from USAID
to institute new schools and training programs. And specific schools are
working hard to encourage critical thinking, among them the Episcopal schools
on the Central Plateau where I went during the Tabasamu trip and the nursing school.
As I look at the plethora of problems in Haiti, I increasingly come to the
conclusion that nothing can help them but a stronger system of education.
No comments:
Post a Comment